Read the given extracts and answer the questions for ANY ONE of the two, given.
What are the moral dilemmas that Sadao faces in the story? How does he resolve them? Explain with reference to the text.
Answer written by the student is:
The moral dilemmas that Sadao faces in the story are:
- Whether to save the life of an enemy soldier or to let him die as a patriot. 🩺🗡️
- Whether to report the presence of the soldier to the authorities or to keep it a secret as a humanitarian. 🚓🤐
- Whether to risk his own safety and reputation or to get rid of the soldier as soon as possible. 😨😠
He resolves them by:
- Saving the life of the soldier as a doctor, but also planning to hand him over to his servant who would kill him and throw him into the sea. He does this because he believes that he cannot violate his oath as a doctor, but he also cannot betray his country and his emperor. 🙏🗡️
- Keeping the presence of the soldier a secret as a humanitarian, but also telling his father-in-law about it and asking for his advice. He does this because he does not want to be responsible for the death of a man he has just saved, but he also does not want to face the consequences of his actions. 🤐👴
- Risking his own safety and reputation by keeping the soldier in his house until he recovers, but also hoping that he would leave his house soon and no one would ever know what he had done. He does this because he feels sorry for the soldier and grateful for his gratitude , but he also fears for his own life and honor. 😢😓
Step-by-step explanation of the answer is:
To answer this question, we need to identify the moral dilemmas that Sadao faces in the story and explain how he resolves them. We also need to refer to the text to support our answer. 📖
- A moral dilemma is a situation where a person has to choose between two or more options that involve ethical principles or values. It can be difficult and stressful to make such a decision, especially when there are conflicting loyalties or consequences involved. 😕
- In this story, Sadao faces three moral dilemmas that relate to his roles as a doctor, a citizen, and a human being. He has to balance his professional duty, his patriotic loyalty, and his humanitarian compassion. He also has to deal with the risks and uncertainties that come with his choices. 😟
- The first moral dilemma that Sadao faces is whether to save the life of an enemy soldier or to let him die as a patriot. 🩺
- The second moral dilemma that Sadao faces is whether to report the presence of the soldier to the authorities or to keep it a secret as a humanitarian.🚓
- The third moral dilemma that Sadao faces is whether to risk his own safety and reputation or to get rid of the soldier as soon as possible.😨